Alexander's success stemmed from a potent combination of talent and grit. He possessed a deceptive curveball and a fastball that kept hitters guessing. More importantly, he displayed a fierce competitive spirit that pushed him to excel, even in the face of adversity. His work ethic was legendary, often pitching complete games on short rest. This relentless drive earned him the respect of his teammates and the fear of opponents.

Beyond wins, Alexander's accolades speak volumes. He won three pitching Triple Crowns, a feat signifying the league leader in wins, earned run average (ERA), and strikeouts. He led his team to the 1926 World Series championship with the St. Louis Cardinals, a crowning achievement in a career filled with individual and collective triumphs.

Despite a decline in later years, Alexander retired in 1930 with a remarkable .642 winning percentage, ranking among the highest in baseball history. His dedication to the game and fierce competitiveness cemented his place in the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1938.